This headline ran in the New York Times, July 4, 2012:
Neighborhood Tensions Flare at Reopened McCarren Pool
“What should have been a simple kickoff to summer in New York has turned fraught, with capacity crowds, racially charged debates and complaints that the city should have committed more resources to the opening, from sanitation to security.”
If were mayor of New York City I would grab Police Commissioner Ray Kelly and go swimming at the McCarren Pool in Brooklyn. I would get people from the NYPD and every other city agency to talk and LISTEN to people waiting in line about how they would like to treated at the pool. The police would be in uniform. The insignia would say ‘We are proud stakeholders in this neighborhood and will make it safe and open for all.’ They would hand out water, make friends and identify potential fresh ba—–s.
The City’s mission would be to help the people using the pool to use it in peace and fun. They wouldn’t quit until the pool was peaceful.
The idea of the McCarren Pool is the vision of the best of our founding fathers and mothers. They could have had no conception of the eventual global diversity of big cities. But even in 1776 the best of them, though overwhelmingly Protestant and English, knew Africans, Irish, Germans, Scots, French, Poles and others and saw them as “we the people.”
Cities at their best are the places we become Americans. It can be a long, rough process but it bends toward comity. Maybe we stay or maybe by the third generation we are telling stories about our grandparents back in Williamsburg or Dorchester. Somehow it fits that the park and pool are named for a son of Irish parents who fled The Famine. Patrick H. McCarren was born in East Cambridge, Massachusetts, moved to Brooklyn, and made his way up the Democratic ladder to become a state senator (albeit one who gambled at the track and grew to like Gilded Age plutocrats too much).
If you read the article that follows you’ll see the missed opportunities…
by LISA W. FODERARO
“When McCarren Park Pool reopened in Brooklyn last week after 28 years, it was hailed as a grand civic achievement and, perhaps, a milestone for a new social dynamic in New York City, one in which people of different racial, ethnic and class backgrounds could socialize — or at least pursue the same activity — together.
A place where the children of hipster artists, attracted by the upscale restoration with its designer flourishes, would play Marco Polo with youngsters from public housing.
As Jonathan Marvel, the project’s architect, put it, “As architects, it is our goal to contribute spaces that inspire community involvement and face time with each other.”
But within days, that excitement has been replaced by apprehension. Two fights at the pool on the Greenpoint-Williamsburg border and several arrests confirmed the fears of some residents that the giant pool, with a capacity of 1,500, might draw an unruly crowd to a neighborhood divided among older residents of Italian and Polish descent, gentrifying newcomers and Hispanic families.
What should have been a simple kickoff to summer in New York has turned fraught, with capacity crowds, racially charged debates and complaints that the city should have committed more resources to the opening, from sanitation to security.
“I’m not happy and not because of the pool, but because of the fighting,” said Tony Otero, 71, who has lived near the pool for 25 years. “It’s not good for the community. It’s trouble. All kinds of kids are coming here.”
Hot weather and the pool’s reopening generated so much interest that by Friday, a day after its opening, the place was reaching its capacity early in the day. With a line of hundreds snaking around the block on the weekend, the crowd outside grew restless. Nearby merchants complained that pool visitors tossed litter on the ground, tagged buildings with graffiti and relieved themselves in public.
Inside the pool on Friday, teenagers scuffled with a lifeguard who had ordered them to stop doing back flips, and the pool closed an hour early. On Monday, two police officers were injured by swimmers who also persisted in doing back flips. Three men were arrested and charged with assault in the second degree, inciting to riot, criminal nuisance and menacing. More security has been apparent in recent days.
Meredith Chesney, owner of Mousey Brown beauty salon near the pool, said she came out on Saturday morning to discover three new markings of graffiti on her roll-down security gate.
“I thought, ‘O.K., it’s Brooklyn, it’s not that surprising,’ ” she said. “But then, 30 minutes later, I went outside to water my plants and I found someone had defecated right in front of the salon. It’s shocking.”
Still, Ms. Chesney did not fault the would-be pool users; she was holding city officials responsible for not thinking through the potential trouble. There are bathrooms inside McCarren Pool, on Lorimer Street, and in the park itself, but she urged portable toilets for the line outside. (On Wednesday, signs were installed directing those waiting in line toward the park bathrooms.)
“It’s almost Machiavellian how our public administration thinks they can realize these grand ideals for giant public pools without real infrastructure, like bathrooms,” she said. “It’s really setting the public up to fail. It’s very disheartening.”
McCarren Pool, which holds almost 1.1 million gallons of water, is one of the biggest in the city and has a complicated history. It opened along with 10 others in 1936 in the depths of the Depression with Works Progress Administration money, under the auspices of Mayor Fiorello H. La Guardia and the parks commissioner and master builder Robert Moses. After sliding into disrepair, McCarren was shuttered in 1984.
While the other 1936 pools were all renovated, McCarren remained closed, its reopening delayed not only by a lack of money, but also by a debate over its future. Some preservationists lobbied for a full-scale restoration, while neighborhood activists demanded its demolition, in part to prevent outsiders from using it. Some of the blog posts and comments in recent days have echoed the racially tinged dialogue of the 1980s, with neighbors of the pool blaming teenagers from outside the community. In fact, two of the men arrested came from a public housing complex, the Marcy Houses, on the border of Williamsburg and Bedford-Stuyvesant. The other lives across the street from the pool.
The area around the pool has changed significantly in the past few years. Census data show that both the Williamsburg and Greenpoint neighborhoods have had an influx of white residents in the past decade.
For example, in Williamsburg, which has attracted waves of artists in recent years, the non-Hispanic white population increased by 24,000 from 2000 to 2010, while the Hispanic population fell by 10,000. Hispanics now make up 33 percent of the 111,000 residents, with blacks representing 6 percent.
Some of the pressure on McCarren reflects the fact that some neighboring communities, like Bushwick, do not have large outdoor pools. On Tuesday, a number of visitors to McCarren were from Bushwick, waiting in a long line after the pool filled to capacity.
“Just because you come from another neighborhood or another borough or the other side of Brooklyn doesn’t mean you’re the one causing trouble,” said Luis Morales, 42, of Bushwick. “It has to do with a few individuals who are spoiling it for everybody.
“There are good ones and bad ones, from every neighborhood. Judging isn’t right. You could be black, white, green — it doesn’t matter as long as you’re not bothering anyone.”
The city’s parks department defended the pool’s first week. “Thousands of New Yorkers are enjoying McCarren Park Pool’s beautiful renovation, getting exercise and keeping cool during this heat wave,” said Kevin Jeffrey, the Brooklyn parks commissioner. “The few minor incidents have not impacted the vast majority of pool attendees, just as similar incidents at pools across the city don’t stop New Yorkers from enjoying themselves.”
Still, the problems at McCarren Pool have prompted the New York Police Department to put plainclothes officers at the site, and one of the police’s “temporary headquarters vehicles” is parked nearby.
Alexander D. Garvin, a professor of urban planning and management at the Yale School of Architecture and the author of “Public Parks: The Key to Livable Communities,” credited the public pools with providing a crucial outlet for all New Yorkers. “The swimming pools are one of the great legacies of Robert Moses,” he said. “They were designed to be very grand, on a level of the public works of ancient Rome.”
He added: ‘People say that in those days residents lived in tenements and they were crowded and that the pools were an extraordinary release in the hot summer. But guess what? The summer of 2012 is a hot summer, and we have immigrants living several families to one apartment because there is not adequate housing. I don’t see an extreme difference between the need for these pools then and now.'”
Joseph Goldstein, Juliet Linderman and Eric P. Newcomer contributed reporting.